| Xindak FS-1
Speaker Cable |
|
A Reference Cable at a
Reasonable Price |
|
Keith Forrest |
|
26 May
2003 |
Specifications
Copper foil with a 24K
gold-plated plug and RF interference-proof short circuit
ring. Price: 1 meter pair - $595, Additional meter
$150
Address: Bertrand Audio Imports (US
Distributor) 49 Fairview Ave. Nashua, NH
03060 Telephone: 603-883-1982 Fax:
603-880-4533 Email:
BertrandAudio@attbi.com Website: http://www.bertrandaudio.com/ Website:
http://www.xindakaudio.com/
Xindak
is a Chinese company that has been manufacturing high
quality audio components, cables, and even loudspeakers
since 1988, but only recently have they began entering
the U.S. audio market. I'm not sure why they chose now
to do it, but I am glad they finally took the plunge. I
had heard positive reports about the new Xindak SACD
tube output player, but I had not heard anything about
their other product offerings. Frankly, I didn't even
realize that Xindak there were any other product
offerings until I visited a friend of mine, Fred Nadel
of Pureaudio (http://www.pureaudio.net/) in
Scotts Valley, CA. Fred asked me if I wanted to demo
some high performance speaker cables that were new to
the United States. Does a baby like candy? How could I
say no? That day he sent me home with a three-meter pair
of the Xindak FS-01 speaker cables. I have yet to unhook
them from my system.
Not much information is
included in the FS-01 cable box. My demo pair was
terminated with banana plugs at the amp end and spades
at the speaker end. The cables have directional marking
on small silver cylinders, which precede each end of
termination. The Xindak FS-01 retail price is $595 for
the first meter with every additional meter being $150.
According to Xindak's website the FS-01 speaker
cable is
"
… is manufactured with 5N single-crystal non-oxygen
copper foil that is smelted according to the imported
special technology, and adopts the delicate craft of
sandwich style. The terminal is fixed with RF
inhibiting rings acting as the strong barrier to free
radio waves. This type of wire has the characters of
excellent analytic capability, fine transparence,
superior musical balance, diversified levels, harmonic
tones, wonderful hearing, melodic mid-frequency, deep
low-frequency and marvelous elasticity and
strength."
In hindsight, this unique
description of the FS-01 speaker cables by Xindak
conclusively proved to me that an audio manufacturer
does not have to have a good grasp on the English
language to make a cable that has characters of
excellent analytic capability, fine transparence,
superior musical balance, diversified levels, harmonic
tones, wonderful hearing, melodic mid-frequency, deep
low-frequency and marvelous elasticity and strength.
Whoa! All I can say is their English is a lot better
than my Mandarin. I was jazzed at being able to try such
a new product.
Initial Listening
I got home from Fred's at
around 11:00 p.m. and did some casual listening
comparing the musical sound of my system to his system.
This was not really a fair comparison because the retail
on Fred's speakers (over $45K) is more than the retail
price of my entire system. But I began wondering if the
Xindak cables could really be as good as he said? So at
around midnight I decided to hook them up and start
breaking them in. Not expecting too much, I started
doing some initial listening.
The first disc I
put in was Unauthorized by the group Dave's True
Story. This Chesky CD has some delicious female vocal
tracks sung by the sultry Kelly Flint. The immediate
attribute that was apparent as the music began was that
I gained about 2 db of volume (gain) with the addition
of the Xindak cables. I had to adjust the volume down a
notch on my preamp to reach the same volume level I had
before. I never heard such a substantial change in gain
when changing out speaker cables in the past. And this
was only the beginning.
The next initial sonic
attribute that I noted was the amount of detail that
these speaker cables let pass to the speakers. The
noisefloor of these cables was lower than any cable I
had ever heard and these cables were not even broken in
yet. I let the system play for about 60 hours straight
before I made any real judgments. However, my initial
impression of these Xindak cables was positive to say
the least.
My Listening Tastes
I listen to a wide range of
music, but my hot buttons are jazz and female vocalists.
Combine the two and I melt like ice on summer asphalt. I
think that Norah Jones deserved every Grammy she won.
Anyone that can record a mostly country album in a jazz
style with that much soul and be that popular, I simply
worship. Not to mention the recording is great for a
mass market commercial disc. Blue Note records some very
good stuff. The vinyl is also stellar. Additionally, I
listen to a lot of Chesky recordings. Many critics knock
Chesky for not having 'A-list talent'. They complain
that the Chesky recordings are stellar but the
performances are not nearly up to the standards of the
recordings. These critics need to enjoy the music and
listen to more Chesky discs. They should also remember:
"Those that do not have talent tend to become
critics." … Doh! I make no excuses for my
lack of talent. Chesky does though have some talented
artists. I think David Mamet is a lucky guy to be
married to the beautiful Rebecca Pidgeon. She has an
angelic voice and a musical style that is all her own. I
like using Ms. Pidgeon's albums as reference recordings
because they are recorded well and she speaks with such
a Scottish accent that understanding what she says is a
good evaluating yardstick for a system's midrange
resolution.
The only thing I could ever fault
Jennifer Warnes for is that she has not put out enough
solo albums and original material. She could have sung
any type of music from opera to punk rock if she wanted
to. And those of us who are not opera and punk rock
fanatics are very glad she chose to sing folk/pop. Do I
need to even mention my extreme attraction to Patricia
Barber's music? Even though I am smitten with female
vocalists, I enjoy everything from opera/classical to
some heavy metal/punk. My favorite classical composer is
Mozart, probably because I had to dissect several of his
pieces in college. But enough about me, now on to the
review….
Critical Listening
After two and a half days of
break in, I again (call me a creature of habit) put in
Dave's True Story's, Unauthorized, and did some
critical listening. The Ayre CX-7 in my system is a fine
one box CD player that can compete with digital costing
two times as much. It has a wonderful synergy with the
K-3x preamplifier and V-5x amp. The Ayre sound in total
tends to be detailed, fast and remarkably liquid for
solid state.
Kelly Flynt's voice on the
Unauthorized CD covers both the upper and lower
midrange frequencies. Her vocals sounded more natural,
detailed, and open than I have ever heard. This natural
midrange came at what seemed like no sacrifice to the
bass and treble. Many cables and components that seem to
have magical midranges many times achieve these results
through certain sacrifices or tricks, such as: rolling
off of the treble, enhancing the mid or upper bass,
rolling off of the bass, or just plain enhancing the
midrange. The Xindak seems to sacrifice nothing to
achieve a midrange that is exceptionally detailed and
clean. Kelly's voice was open and alive-sounding on this
disc. On other equipment and cables, I have heard her
voice sound like it is coming from a hallway, sounding
dark and constricted. Not so with the Xindak in my
system. The Dave's True Story disc made me feel like I
was in a large church with Kelly Flint's voice
backdropped against a natural, acoustically
live-sounding environment. The album was recorded live
in a church. The sound of her voice on track 8, is just
seductively delicious.
The Xindak's bass is both
deep and controlled. Frequencies that are lower than
most of us can hear (Under 30 Hz), I could feel in my
bones with the Xindak in my system. Many times I listen
casually from my computer situated on the side of my
listening room. While working on my computer, I could
feel low frequencies in my legs that I had never felt
before. The Vienna Acoustics Mahler speakers can play
down to 22 Hz, and their two 10" woofers per speaker are
a challenge for many a music system to drive. The Mahler
speakers are, above all, musical. They do just about
everything asked of a speaker very well. However, any
bass problems electronics or cables have will be
ruthlessly revealed by the Mahlers. Components or cables
with no bass, tubby bass, slow bass, boomy bass, over
the top bass, or seriously uncontrolled bass, need not
apply to drive the Mahlers. The Xindak FS-01 cables were
rock-solid driving the Mahlers. The bass was as tight
and clean as I have ever heard the Mahlers driven. They
also revealed a certain amount of detail in the bass
that I had never heard before. On the Eagles recording,
When Hell Freezes Over, I noticed on "Hotel
California" that the drum which is introduced early in
the song, has an interesting echo texture right before
the decay that I had never noticed before in the
recording. Listening a bit closer, I realized that this
texture I was hearing was not an echo derived from a
single drum on every beat, but on a few beats there is a
deeper drum that immediately follows the decay of the
initial drum beat. I had never noticed this detail
before in the recording. This Eagles recording is not my
favorite, mainly because I think Don Henley's vocals are
recorded poorly, but some of the instruments themselves
are recorded quite well (this extreme contrast of
recording quality is what bothers me every time I hear
the album). Nevertheless, I could shut my eyes and
imagine Joe Walsh playing guitar in front of me during
his solo in "Hotel California." Macro as well as micro
dynamics were astonishing. Between some of the insane
drums and bass notes on the album, I felt the Xindak
cables were able to convey the dynamic range of even the
loudest instruments. This observation was confirmed
later when I played track 10 of the Titanic
soundtrack. This track yielded dynamics from the Mahlers
that caused a chill to crawl up my spine. There was a
certain effortlessness in the music that flowed from the
Mahlers, be it during soft or loud passages. This might
have more to do with the Ayre V-5x amp's vice-like grip
on the Mahlers. The Ayre V-5x might be the solid state
amplifier to beat in the sub $5000 price range of
amplifiers. This amp is a perfect match with the K-3x
preamplifier. The V-5x is the first amp that I have
owned that was able to control the lower end of the
Mahler speakers with incredible authority and sound
clean and fast at the same time. The FS-01 speaker
cables let the Ayre V-5x dominate the Mahlers like a
strict but benevolent mistress without exerting any type
of real tonal sonic signature on the music that I could
detect.
Next up was Norah Jones', Come Away
With Me. I have this album on CD and vinyl, and if
you hear it on vinyl first, the CD is simply a let down
(as with most CD's compared to their vinyl
counterparts). I popped it in, and let Norah work her
magic. Many copper cables sacrifice top end treble. Some
of these cables roll off the top and the midrange seems
to come to the forefront. If there is a top roll off
with these Xindak cables, I cannot hear it. Xindak does
make the FS-2, a copper/silver mixture speaker cable
that is more expensive than this FS-01. The FS-2
supposedly gives a little more extension to the top end
and provides ever so little more resolution. I have been
told that to hear this difference, you need a system
with the utmost resolution to make this determination.
The upper treble was extended and natural with the
Xindak cables. If there is a slight roll off, I could
not detect it. And I do not have a silver wire in the
signal path in this system. The interconnect I use is
Jena Labs Symphony. The Jena Labs Symphony interconnect
has been around for many years. Unlike many fad cables
it has no gimmicks other than it is extremely pure
copper that is cryogenically frozen. The Symphony cables
are the most natural sounding interconnects I have tried
in my system. Overall tonal balance of my system with
the Xindak FS-01 cables was as neutral as I have ever
heard my system sound. Past speaker cables that I have
owned (some far exceeding the cost of the FS-01 cables),
never presented the kind of detail that the FS-01 cables
did. With the FS-01, Norah Jones sounded oh so soulful,
and I could hear every little oscillation of her voice
that was captured by her microphone. During the song
"Lonestar", there is a part where Norah has a harmony
accompanist. The harmony is very subtle, and on a mid-fi
system one may not realize it is a second singer. Even
on a resolving music system, a person might figure that
this vocal was overdubbed and only backdrops Norah's
voice. With the Xindak cables, the harmony vocalist is
separated from Norah's voice in the soundstage
presentation of my system. Norah's voice is to the right
of the center of the soundstage, and the harmony vocal
is to the left of the center of the soundstage. This is
a very subtle and resolving achievement for my system.
Playing well recorded live music, showed just
how well my system was able to soundstage with the
Xindak cables. My audiophile friend Frankenfurter (his
nickname is Frankenfurter, I would have nicknamed him
Lars but that was already taken) came to visit recently.
He brought over some newly released JVC XRCD24s. These
are XRCDs that are mastered and mixed at 24bit
resolution that are only converted to 16bit in the last
step of production. I have a lot of well recorded
digital, but I was dumbstruck by these XRCDs. The two
XRCD24 albums we listened to were astonishing: Art
Pepper, Landscape, and Tsuyoshi Ymamato Trio,
Girl Talk. These two digital recordings were as
close to vinyl as I have ever heard digital sound in my
system. There is lots of hope for 16bit digital, and it
is JVC XRCD24! The soundstage on these live recordings
was presented with such precision and detail, I knew
which way the piano was facing and I knew precisely were
all of the instrument players were. At one point during
our listening session, I looked over at my turntable to
see how much time we had on the side of the record… DOH!
My idle turntable reminded me that we were listening to
digital. I could not believe the natural musical
instrument textures that my system conveyed from these
XRCDs. Never had I heard such resolution or organic
analog-like instrument presence except on well recorded
vinyl.
As I listened to more and more
recordings, I noted that the depth and width of the
soundstage was deeper and wider than I had heard my
system ever convey before. Images were delivered with
pinpoint precision with a new found stability and
continuity. Instruments seemed to have a more three
dimensional organic presence. This type of presence I
normally associate with analog. I am not going to say
these speaker cables make your digital sound like vinyl,
but they do present well recorded instruments with such
detail that will make you either appreciate your digital
source or desperately want to upgrade it.
My Rega
P9 turntable with RB1000 tonearm setup in my system is a
great non tweaking turntable. I am relatively new to
vinyl, and I do not enjoy constantly fiddling with
analog to get it to sound divine. You set this turntable
up one time, and it is good to go virtually forever. To
get objectively better than the P9, megabucks must be
spent. The Benz Micro Glider 2 cartridge is a well
rounded cartridge that seems to have a lot of synergy
with my P9 and Ayre phono preamp. The Ayre K-3x
preamplifier with phono option is an amazingly solid all
in one linestage and phono preamp combo. It can have as
much as 60db gain in the phono stage. The line stage
preamplification is musical. It is not the final word in
transparency, but it is somewhere in the same
sentence.
Putting on the Come Away With Me
LP, I was transfixed by how much dramatically better my
analog sounds when compared to my digital. I played side
two for my audiophile friend Frankenfurter. Afterward he
had a look of disbelief on his face, and said that he
always thought Come Away With Me had some sort of
grit or noise in the vinyl pressing compared to the CD.
This was the first time he had heard the album without
the grit or noise. And Frankenfurter has a vinyl setup I
drool over. I was dumbstruck by his comment. This is the
first time he had heard my system with the Xindak FS-01
cables. Whenever I seem to make an improvement in my
system between my preamp and my speakers, my vinyl
always gets the most benefit from the upgrade. I have to
agree with Frankenfurter, my analogue gained a certain
clarity with the Xindak speaker cables.
Build
quality of the XIndak FS-01 cables is the only thing I
can remotely fault this cable for. The build quality is
good; however, the cables themselves can be bent if
stepped on accidentally. CDs also make great skeets but
doing so makes them ultimately unplayable. A little
caution must be heeded when you are stepping around the
Xindak FS-01 speaker cables. The sheath around the cable
does nothing to protect it against possible damage from
traumatic forces. However, this kind of build quality is
nothing new to most ribbon/foil speaker cables as they
all seem prone to getting kinks. Additionally, the
banana plugs do not look quite as sturdy as the spades.
Go with the spade option for terminations if you
can.
Summary
There is an unwritten rule
in audio that to get reference audio components, a
person has to spend megabucks. Many audiophiles will
deny this rule, but they forget that reference means a
product designed without compromises. Someone forgot to
inform Xindak of this rule. Maybe it just does not
translate well into Mandarin? I am not going to say
these are the best speaker cables ever made. I cannot
make this determination. However, these Xindak FS-01
speaker cables are hands down the most musical,
transparent, and just plain tonally correct speaker
cables I have ever had in my system. If Xindak made any
compromises in designing this cable, I cannot hear them.
I am judging these speaker cables in the sub $1000
speaker cable class. In this area, these speaker cables
have no peer that I know of. Are they reference? Are
they without compromise? Quite possibly, but careful
listeners will need to make that determination for
themselves. I strongly recommend anyone demo these
cables before buying new speaker cables-no matter what
your working budget is. The Xindak FS-01 could save you
a lot of money, or they may just entice you to spend a
little more to get better transparency than other cables
anywhere near their price point. Nevertheless, these
speaker cables may not work in every system due to their
extreme transparency. These speaker cables will brutally
reveal any system's sonic problems in the musical
presentation. In the end these cables have revealed to
me the sound of the upstream components of my system to
a degree I did not think possible for a speaker cable in
this sub $1000 price range. These Xindak FS-01 speaker
cables make me want to upgrade all of my sources. When
will this madness end? I do, oh so love this
madness…

|